Mobile Links
We Must Ignite This Couch Articles



EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown

By Jude
2009/06/30

**Alert- This is a highly nerdy, highly specific article. Those who aren't NCAA Football video game dorks should go about their business. Nothing to see here**

Because on many levels I could be loosely described as a "geek", I've been spending the last couple of weeks searching for the player ratings for the Mountaineers on NCAA Football 2010 by EA Sports.

See, I'm the type of football fan that suffers through the summer as if it was a dark, wet swamp, infested with mosquitos, so hot and humid that your skin feels like it weighs 500 pounds. And the football season on the other side is a tropic breeze as you sit on the beach with a cold beer in one hand and something buxom in the other. (Until you lose to ECU. Then it's back to the swamp.)

So to bide my time until REAL football arrives, I console myself with the knowledge that even if the actual Mountaineers won't be taking the field for another 4 solid months, the virtual Mountaineers can be kicking all kinds of ass at my command in EA Sports NCAA Football until then. (Unfortunately, to date, the virtual Mountaineers always, always, always do better than the real ones.)

As the game is set to release precisely two weeks from today, I was beginning to think that I would have to actually wait to buy the game to find out whether or not EA Sports would represent the Mountaineers as the college football powerhouse that they are (hang on, I can't see the keyboard through these blue-and-gold-colored glasses).

Alas, all my searching had been in vein until today.

I FINALLY FOUND THE DAMN ROSTERS!!!

As far as the ratings are concerned, it appears as if the Mountaineers will have a sufficient rating to compete, but not even a rating as high as many of their Big East counterparts. And because I know that this can stimulate the sort of conversation that amuses me as I wait for the interminably long off-season to wind down, let me give you a few of the ratings I found.



A collection of those interested in the contents of this article


BIG EAST TEAM RATINGS

(Ratings by overall grade, offense, and defense grades.)

USF B+ B+ B+
Rutgers B B B+
Cincinnati B B+ B+
West Virginia B B+ B-
Pitt B B B
Connecticut C C+ C-
Syracuse D+ C- D+
Louisville C+ B- C

So it would appear that by team ratings alone, EA Sports is expecting the Mountaineers to finish tied with Pitt for 4th place in the Big East. Not looking good so far.


Individual WVU Player Ratings

Obviously, NCAA 10 follows the tradition of all college games and provides only player numbers instead of names for the rosters of a given team. (For example, Jarrett Brown is QB #16 and so forth.)

When it comes to the freshmen, I've lined up the provided height/weight figures with what's listed on WVU's roster, which is never perfect, but should line up pretty well.

Take a look at some of the player ratings for the Mountaineers this year, along with the pertinent specific attributes. (I'm going to limit myself to skill position guys and the projected starters for everything else. Additionally, because my browser is somewhat screwed up, I can only see the overall ratings for the defensive players, so that's what I'll post):

QB
Jarrett Brown: 89 overall, 89 throwing power, 85 accuracy, 85 speed



Thought we were through having badass QB's in Morgantown? Come get some, noobs!!


Coley White: 84 overall, 87 throwing power, 82 accuracy, 87 speed

Gino Smith: 81 overall, 85 throwing power, 84 accuracy, 81 speed


RB
Noel Devine: 94 overall, 96 speed, 96 agility, 95 elusiveness (damn!)

Tavon Austin: 82 overall, 92 speed, 92 agility, 82 elusiveness

Mark Rodgers: 85 overall, 90 speed, 90 agility, 85 break tackle


FB/TE
Tyler Urban: 77 overall, 79 speed, 66 catch, 80 pass block, 79 run block


WR
Alric Arnett: 90 overall, 91 speed, 92 acceleration, 88 catch

Jock Sanders: 90 overall, 92 speed, 92 agility, 86 catch



Suspended or not, Jock's in the game. EA got no love for driving under the influence arrests.


Wes Lyons: 87 overall, 88 speed, 86 catch, 90 jumping (up button when you're throwing, boys and girls)

Bradley Starks: 85 overall, 88 speed, 87 catch, 79 throw power, 76 throw accuracy (had to throw that in just in case we've got some cheesers reading this that want to play him at QB)

Logan Heastie: 84 overall, 93 speed, 93 acceleration, 80 catch


O-line
Don Barclay: 89 overall, 88 pass block, 90 run block

Josh Jenkins: 86 overall, 86 pass block, 89 run block

Chad Snodgrass: 87 overall, 88 pass block, 89 run block

Eric Jobe: 86 overall, 86 pass block, 87 run block

Selvish Capers: 93 overall, 89 pass block, 94 run block


D-line
Scooter Berry- 81 ovr

Chris Neild- 80

Thor Merrow- 85 (Still on the game, even if he's not on the team. Strange, strange rating.)

Julian Miller- 77


Linebackers
Reed Williams- 85

Anthony Leonard- 75

JT Thomas- 73

Pat Lazear- 81 (Very strange that they would make Lazear better than either Leonard or JT Thomas)


Cornerbacks
Brandon Hogan- 84 overall, 90 speed

Kent Richardson- 81 overall, 91 speed

Guesley Dervil- 82 overall, 91 speed

Brantwan Bowser- 77 overall, 92 speed (this is my best guess as to who this guy is. I spent 10 minutes trying to figure out who was the #33 sophomore DB until I finally gave up.)


Safeties

Quinton Andrews- 81 overall, 90 speed



That's right. Q's still on the team in virtual NCAAland. He better not be a problem for this coach, though, because I'll not only cut him, I'll delete the mfer.


Robert Sands- 79 overall, 88 speed

Sidney Glover- 80 overall, 89 speed

Nate Sowers- 67 overall, 86 speed, 86 throw power, 84 throw accuracy (surprising that they still give him credit for his QB prowess.)


Kickers
Scott Kozlowski aka puntazgetsl8d: 84 overall



All praise the comedy gods. This is going to be a fun season for me and the Kozman.


Tyler Bitancurt- 81 (even though they got his number and year wrong, this must be him)



Summary

The typical roster problems arrive from NCAA Football games in being unable to identify certain players by number, year status, or otherwise, but overall this seems like a relatively fair rating for most of the players on the Mountaineers. The most glaring flaw is the rating of the defensive linemen, as there wasn't a single person that watched a WVU football game last year that came away honestly believing that Thor Merrow was better than Chris Neild or Scooter Berry.

Additionally, Reed Williams as an 85 rating apparently disregards his pre-injury abilities in favor of a more wait-and-see perspective.

But WVU fans should be pleased that the wide receiver corp is infinitely better on the game this year than in any year I can remember, and the skill positions are as solid as one could possibly expect given the situation WVU is in this year.

So if you happen to be a nerd who happens to like the Mountaineers and also happens to play college football video games, things could be worse...



Read Jude's weBLog | Comments (18) | Trackback (0)
Trackback URL of this entry
http://www.wemustignitethiscouch.com/modules/weblog/weblog-tb.php/3224
Printer Friendly Page Send this Blog to a Friend
The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content.
Poster Thread
WVUWILD12
Posted: 6/30/2009 6:42 pm  Updated: 6/30/2009 6:42 pm
Here for the Beer
Joined: 4/23/2009
From: Princeton, West Virginia
Posts: 389
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
All of the player ratings seem reasonable, except I thought Tavon should be faster, and Jock and Starks possibly a little faster. Only one question though, why did Noel's speed decrease? Last year he was a 97 this year he is a 96?
eersfan185
Posted: 6/30/2009 9:26 pm  Updated: 6/30/2009 9:26 pm
Here for the Beer
Joined: 2/23/2009
From: ona wv
Posts: 275
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
Did I read that Thomas is rated a 73 ovr? WTF???
minkeun_2000
Posted: 7/1/2009 12:35 am  Updated: 7/1/2009 12:35 am
Grant Ave. Warrior
Joined: 7/24/2007
From: Beckley, WV
Posts: 799
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
our whole d looks like ass.

i think hogan should be 90+ and jt thomas? dont even get me started on his ranking.

our offense is pretty consistent i guess but they really butchered us for our defense this year.
msaul37
Posted: 7/1/2009 4:51 am  Updated: 7/1/2009 4:51 am
Joined: 7/27/2006
From: Alkol, Lincoln County
Posts: 12329
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
first, 'jarrett brown is #17'.. wtf jude. w t f.

second, they better have our updated stadium on this s***. i see a plain section number on the walls rather than the blue light up thingies. they also better have the damn ribbon board and scoreboard.. since that's all we had to talk about last year during the preseason.

third, thurr be no hatin' for the 3-7, doyahfeelmeh?!
gameface25
Posted: 7/1/2009 9:55 am  Updated: 7/1/2009 9:59 am
Pitt Hater
Joined: 9/10/2007
From: Roanoke, VA
Posts: 2027
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
MSaul pretty sure WVU's stadium was one of the overhauls on this years game. I know they updated alot of places, and ours is supposed to be one.

Im one of these geeks who is into this game so, my opinions:

I think overall its a pretty good roster for us, ratings wise. They gave Noel some serious love, I like it. They prob overrated Coley quite a bit tho, and with that speed I can see the cheesers using the hell out of him online.

I agree with the assessment on Reed, he should have been a 89-91 ish LB as our Impact player on D...

Im pretty sure whoever the EA tech that researched our stats got JT and Lazear mixed up on the ratings and who was who.

But having those impact freshmen around 84ish overall is a good thing. by the time they are seniors on the game they will be mid 90s
Jude
Posted: 7/1/2009 10:24 am  Updated: 7/1/2009 10:24 am
WMITC
Joined: 1/20/2006
From: Eastern Panhandle, WV
Posts: 2308
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
Lighten up, Marty. It was a typo. Damn. lol

And I agree with your assessments as well, gameface. Sometimes the rosters don't make much sense, and the JT Thomas rating seems to be the most indefensible rating for our whole team. I mean, does anyone really believe that Coley White is better at being a QB at this stage than JT Thomas is at being a LB?
PB
Posted: 7/1/2009 4:23 pm  Updated: 7/1/2009 4:23 pm
Pitt Hater
Joined: 2/13/2006
From: Washington DC
Posts: 1421
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
#1, the defense should, for the first time in a LONG time, be rated higher than the offense.

#2, this year, if you push up, up, down, down, left, right, left, right, A, B, start, Noel Devine will disappear from wherever he is on the field and rematerialize instantly in the endzone. Just like in real life. :)
wvufan1818
Posted: 7/1/2009 11:43 pm  Updated: 7/1/2009 11:43 pm
Grant Ave. Warrior
Joined: 7/8/2008
From: hedgesville WV
Posts: 772
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
Kozlowski is EXTREMELY underrated.
msaul37
Posted: 7/2/2009 7:36 am  Updated: 7/2/2009 7:36 am
Joined: 7/27/2006
From: Alkol, Lincoln County
Posts: 12329
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
lighten up you say?

i need a couch for that
MikeOly
Posted: 7/2/2009 11:20 am  Updated: 7/2/2009 11:20 am
Pitt Hater
Joined: 10/18/2006
From: Washington, DC
Posts: 1627
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
Dear god those are the most hilarious ratings I've ever seen. Coley White with an 84? Jock Sanders is a 90 as a WR?

Thor Merrow higher than Scooter Berry?

They HAVE to have people mixed up, just have to. That or they were smoking meth when they made this.
WVUWILD12
Posted: 7/3/2009 2:21 pm  Updated: 7/3/2009 2:21 pm
Here for the Beer
Joined: 4/23/2009
From: Princeton, West Virginia
Posts: 389
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
hey Jude can you give me the link to where you found this? I would like to check it out.
WVUWILD12
Posted: 7/5/2009 8:50 pm  Updated: 7/5/2009 8:50 pm
Here for the Beer
Joined: 4/23/2009
From: Princeton, West Virginia
Posts: 389
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
Nevermind I found the Rosters Jude but, I have also figured out that the player everyone thinks is Thor Merrow, that is actually supposed to be Tevita Finau.
Jude
Posted: 7/5/2009 10:45 pm  Updated: 7/5/2009 10:45 pm
WMITC
Joined: 1/20/2006
From: Eastern Panhandle, WV
Posts: 2308
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
Nice find, WVUWILD12.

That actually makes sense. I think it was the year that threw everybody (myself included) off.
WVUWILD12
Posted: 7/7/2009 10:57 am  Updated: 7/7/2009 10:57 am
Here for the Beer
Joined: 4/23/2009
From: Princeton, West Virginia
Posts: 389
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
Yeah it threw me off too Jude, the only way I figured it out was I was thinking to myself there's no way the guys at EA are dumb enough to put Thor Merrow on here and make him that good. So I looked up the height and weight and year of Tevita and it all was a relatively close match so I knew it had to be him.
WVUonetime
Posted: 7/7/2009 7:12 pm  Updated: 7/7/2009 7:12 pm
Noob
Joined: 7/7/2009
From: Morgantown/NJ
Posts: 28
 NCAA 10 Simulation WVU @ Louisville
http://www.operationsports.com/videoview.php?id=431


Kinda cool...But lets pray to God this has no indication of what we look like this year....
BeastoftheEast
Posted: 7/15/2009 12:46 pm  Updated: 7/15/2009 12:46 pm
WMITC
Joined: 7/21/2006
From: Boone County, WV
Posts: 9803
 Re: NCAA 10 Simulation WVU @ Louisville
I need to go out and get this game. Truthfully though I was sorta disappointed by the last few editions (at least for PS3). The features like the high school playoffs were good, but some of the stuff in stadium that I thought was sorta fun is gone like the interactive crowd.

The feature in one of the older games that you could make signs was comedy gold too. Do you realize how many signs were made at Lee Corso's expense? (Hey it's EA's fault for making a default "Lee Corso is a football genius" sign that can be edited)
jeffro150
Posted: 7/20/2009 8:25 pm  Updated: 7/20/2009 8:25 pm
Here for the Beer
Joined: 1/3/2008
From: Saint Albans
Posts: 321
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
i'm thinking the def back #33 is probably tandy and should be # 38.. remember he filled in for b hogan in the bowl game and he is a soph
convEERted
Posted: 8/5/2009 8:36 am  Updated: 8/5/2009 8:36 am
Grant Ave. Warrior
Joined: 8/23/2006
From: Charleston, WV
Posts: 1073
 Re: EA Sports NCAA Football 2010- WVU breakdown
On playing this game...er...anybody else having a seriously difficult time playing online because EA sports gave our O-Line no respect? Noel down in the backfield on every play, JB has no time to throw the ball!
Login
Username:

Password:

remember me




Copyright © 2004-2009 wemustignitethiscouch.com All Rights Reserved